Hi Andres, I have a working solution and another approach by Wolfgang: This is not a MWE, and it contains probably a lot of unnecessary stuff. Since Hans fixed some problems since, it might have become much easier. E.g. I seldom need my FNVOffset correction any more. % I thought I could setup those two together, but it didn’t work \setupmargindata[inmargin][ location=right, stack=continue, align=flushright, style={\switchtobodyfont[6pt]}, ] \setupmargindata[inouter][ location=right, stack=continue, align=flushright, style={\switchtobodyfont[6pt]}, ] \def\FNVOffset{0} % Negative vertical offset of footnotes in lines % Redefine this as necessary (e.g. if long footnotes overflow into the footer) \def\MarginNote#1{% \inmargin[ voffset=\dimexpr-\FNVOffset\lineheight\relax, width=\ColWidth, align=flushleft, ]{% \inframed[ width=\ColWidth, align=right, frame=off, offset=overlay, strut=yes, ]{#1}% }% } \define\PlaceFootnote{% \inmargin[ voffset=\dimexpr-\FNVOffset\lineheight\relax, width=\ColWidth, ]{% \vtop{\switchtobodyfont[6pt]\placelocalnotes[footnote][before=,after=]}}% } \def\FNo#1{{#1~}} %\crlf\gobblespacetokens}} % Distance/glue after number or before note text never disappears :( \setupnote[footnote][ location=text, bodyfont=, indenting=no, before={\noindentation}, next=\PlaceFootnote, ] \setupnotation[footnote][ way=bychapter, align=flushleft, indenting=no, location=serried, alternative=serried, width=broad, numbercommand=\FNo, ] % footnote text \setuptexttexts[margin][][% {\framed[ align={flushright,bottom}, frame=off, height=\textheight, width=\ColWidth, ]{% \strut\vfill\switchtobodyfont[6pt]}}% ] %%%% % different approach: \definecounter[Mnote][way=bychapter,prefix=no] \def\mnote#1{% \incrementcounter[Mnote]% \high{\color[mnotemark]{\convertedcounter[Mnote]}}% \inouter{{% \FootnoteFont% \color[mnotemark]{\convertedcounter[Mnote]}\crlf #1\blank[yes]}}% } %%%%% Greetlings, Hraban --- https://www.fiee.net http://wiki.contextgarden.net https://www.dreiviertelhaus.de GPG Key ID 1C9B22FD

Am 2019-10-04 um 03:32 schrieb Andres Conrado Montoya :

I've been tinkering with this problem. It's kind of frustrating not having a right solution for this. After trying and failing to the last solution published by Hraban on 2018-02-12, I tried to implement my own approach, from the other way around, I mean: not trying to implement notes as marginal material, but to implement the marginalia as some type of notes. A different type, apart from footnotes, with their own counter, etc.

Below, a MWE, with some caveats:. 1. This is a poor quality hack. I'm not a developer. 2. If notes are too long, they clash with each other. I tried to understand the options that would allow me to move them up or down, according to the Wiki (https://wiki.contextgarden.net/Command/inmargin), but they don't seem to do anything, or I don't understand how to work with them. But if there is actually a way to manually instruct \inmargin to move up or down, it should be easy to make it work as an optional third argument, for example. 3. The counter introduces some horizontal space that I cant manage to remove except by introducing manual negative \hspace. The MWE doesn't include that space, to display the isse. 4. There are probably a ton of issues I have not thought about, but this seems to work for this project I'm working on, at least.

%%%%%%%%%%% Start MWE

\setuplayout[ topspace=0.722in, header=0.311in, footer=0.622in, width=4.211in, height=9.622in, backspace=1.311in, rightmargin=1.8in, margindistance=24pt ] \definecounter[marginales][way=bytext,prefix=no] \def\romanMarginales{\convertnumber{r}{\rawcountervalue[marginales]}} \def\marginal{\dosingleempty\doMarginal} \def\doMarginal[#1]#2{% \incrementnumber[marginales] \iffirstargument \high{\romanMarginales}\inouter[#1]{\romanMarginales.\ #2} \else \high{\romanMarginales}\inouter{\romanMarginales.\ #2} \fi }

\starttext \dorecurse{6}{\input weisman And so on, and so on\marginal{This is a test, with some words and some more words.}.\par \input thuan\par} \stoptext

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% Stop MWE

Andrés Conrado Montoya Andi Kú andresconrado@gmail.com http://sesentaycuatro.com http://messier87.com http://chiquitico.org ---------------------------------------- Los fines no justifican los medios, porque la medida verdadera de nuestro carácter está dada por los medios que estamos dispuestos a utilizar, no por los fines que proclamamos. ---------------------------------------- “You develop an instant global consciousness, a people orientation, an intense dissatisfaction with the state of the world, and a compulsion to do something about it. From out there on the moon, international politics look so petty. You want to grab a politician by the scruff of the neck and drag him a quarter of a million miles out and say, ‘Look at that, you son of a bitch.’” — Apollo 14 astronaut Edgar Mitchell

___________________________________________________________________________________ If your question is of interest to others as well, please add an entry to the Wiki!

maillist : ntg-context@ntg.nl / http://www.ntg.nl/mailman/listinfo/ntg-context webpage : http://www.pragma-ade.nl / http://context.aanhet.net archive : https://bitbucket.org/phg/context-mirror/commits/ wiki : http://contextgarden.net ___________________________________________________________________________________