a cross-reference query
Hi list, In an attempt to make a dictionary interactive in certain ways, perhaps I am misusing the \in{}[] command here, but sometimes a reference works and sometimes it doesn't. I have no idea why it doesn't. Here is the situation: Each dictionary entry is a section that has been defined as 'entry', hence we have a \startentry[title=,marking=,reference=]...\stopentry structure. Many entries can refer to other entries in the dictionary (in most cases the headword is in Italian, but the definitions, explanations are in English in all cases). in 90% of cases my referencing is working, so here is an example of one that works when \setupinteraction[state=start] is set: \startentry[title={1aetà},marking={1aetà},reference={eta}]\\ 1. youth. 2. first age. {\emnp.} \bullet\enspaceThe age between adolescence and maturity and by extension all of the human being’sfirst age (as opposed to old age). Different cultures distinguish} age groupings in different ways. One would be unlikely to find, in English, terms like first age, second age etc. as recorded here. In fact there are probably only three general groupings in English: young, middle-aged, elderly, and the boundaries are rather flexible for these. Among the young category, English might distinguish infants, children, adolescents young adults. \rightarrow\enspace \in{giovani}[giovani] \stopentry In other words, there is an entry called 'giovani' and it begins \startentry[title={giovani},marking={giovani},reference={giovani}]. That correctly gives me a bold green clickable link which takes me to 'giovani'. There is no number or page reference involved. I simply want the link to take me to the entry concerned. But it does not always work. I have another entry called 'ad nutum' (Latin, not Italian in this case) with a reference to 'segretario' many pages on. I am absolutely sure I have the reference for segretario properly set up, both in its own entry and by calling it as I did for 'giovani', namely this time as \in{segretario}[segretario] but it is not recognized. This is not the only non-working case. There are several. Can anyone give me a hint as to what I might be doing wrong? I realise that usually these references call on page numbers or section numbers, but I don't want/need (or do I?) to use those. I simply the reader to be able to click on a hyperlink which takes them to the referenced entry. Julian
Hi Julian, while I can’t help you with the real issue, a few hints: * Look into the .tuc file for the references. Do you find differences between working and not-working examples? * Do the examples work if you take them out of your big document or if you change the order? * There are “strange” space characters in your message, they disappear in the quoted version below. That might cause troubles in typesetting and referencing. * You don’t need to set "marking" if it’s the same as the title. * It might make sense to use \about instead of \in – \about[eta] would render as “1a età“ * I would define a few macros, e.g. for the \in where both parameters are the same and for stuff like \bullet\enspace – probably you just left these out to simplify the example. Hraban Am 10.05.22 um 04:03 schrieb jbf via ntg-context:
Hi list,
In an attempt to make a dictionary interactive in certain ways, perhaps I am misusing the \in{}[] command here, but sometimes a reference works and sometimes it doesn't. I have no idea why it doesn't. Here is the situation:
Each dictionary entry is a section that has been defined as 'entry', hence we have a \startentry[title=,marking=,reference=]...\stopentry structure. Many entries can refer to other entries in the dictionary (in most cases the headword is in Italian, but the definitions, explanations are in English in all cases). in 90% of cases my referencing is working, so here is an example of one that works when \setupinteraction[state=start] is set:
\startentry[title={1aetà},marking={1aetà},reference={eta}]\\
1. youth. 2. first age. {\emnp.} \bullet\enspaceThe age between adolescence and maturity and by extension all of the human being’sfirst age (as opposed to old age).
Different cultures distinguish} age groupings in different ways. One would be unlikely to find, in English, terms like first age, second age etc. as recorded here. In fact there are probably only three general groupings in English: young, middle-aged, elderly, and the boundaries are rather flexible for these. Among the young category, English might distinguish infants, children, adolescents young adults. \rightarrow\enspace \in{giovani}[giovani]
\stopentry
In other words, there is an entry called 'giovani' and it begins \startentry[title={giovani},marking={giovani},reference={giovani}]. That correctly gives me a bold green clickable link which takes me to 'giovani'. There is no number or page reference involved. I simply want the link to take me to the entry concerned.
But it does not always work. I have another entry called 'ad nutum' (Latin, not Italian in this case) with a reference to 'segretario' many pages on. I am absolutely sure I have the reference for segretario properly set up, both in its own entry and by calling it as I did for 'giovani', namely this time as \in{segretario}[segretario] but it is not recognized. This is not the only non-working case. There are several.
Can anyone give me a hint as to what I might be doing wrong? I realise that usually these references call on page numbers or section numbers, but I don't want/need (or do I?) to use those. I simply the reader to be able to click on a hyperlink which takes them to the referenced entry.
Julian
Thanks Hraban, Taco. It is very helpful to get these hints. I will work through them calmly over the next day or so. Not sure why the spaces disappeared in the message (1 età came out as 1età etc.). Probably because I copy-pasted from the text editor but all spacing is correct in the editor I can assure you. It's a very big document, hundreds of pages, so I even wondered if the size of the document was a factor. But Taco's warning about possible duplicates definitely becomes a possibility in a very large doc! Anyway, I'll work through those hints and see where things are at after that. Julian On 10/5/22 16:47, Henning Hraban Ramm via ntg-context wrote:
Hi Julian,
while I can’t help you with the real issue, a few hints:
* Look into the .tuc file for the references. Do you find differences between working and not-working examples?
* Do the examples work if you take them out of your big document or if you change the order?
* There are “strange” space characters in your message, they disappear in the quoted version below. That might cause troubles in typesetting and referencing.
* You don’t need to set "marking" if it’s the same as the title.
* It might make sense to use \about instead of \in – \about[eta] would render as “1a età“
* I would define a few macros, e.g. for the \in where both parameters are the same and for stuff like \bullet\enspace – probably you just left these out to simplify the example.
Hraban
Am 10.05.22 um 04:03 schrieb jbf via ntg-context:
Hi list,
In an attempt to make a dictionary interactive in certain ways, perhaps I am misusing the \in{}[] command here, but sometimes a reference works and sometimes it doesn't. I have no idea why it doesn't. Here is the situation:
Each dictionary entry is a section that has been defined as 'entry', hence we have a \startentry[title=,marking=,reference=]...\stopentry structure. Many entries can refer to other entries in the dictionary (in most cases the headword is in Italian, but the definitions, explanations are in English in all cases). in 90% of cases my referencing is working, so here is an example of one that works when \setupinteraction[state=start] is set:
\startentry[title={1aetà},marking={1aetà},reference={eta}]\\
1. youth. 2. first age. {\emnp.} \bullet\enspaceThe age between adolescence and maturity and by extension all of the human being’sfirst age (as opposed to old age).
Different cultures distinguish} age groupings in different ways. One would be unlikely to find, in English, terms like first age, second age etc. as recorded here. In fact there are probably only three general groupings in English: young, middle-aged, elderly, and the boundaries are rather flexible for these. Among the young category, English might distinguish infants, children, adolescents young adults. \rightarrow\enspace \in{giovani}[giovani]
\stopentry
In other words, there is an entry called 'giovani' and it begins \startentry[title={giovani},marking={giovani},reference={giovani}]. That correctly gives me a bold green clickable link which takes me to 'giovani'. There is no number or page reference involved. I simply want the link to take me to the entry concerned.
But it does not always work. I have another entry called 'ad nutum' (Latin, not Italian in this case) with a reference to 'segretario' many pages on. I am absolutely sure I have the reference for segretario properly set up, both in its own entry and by calling it as I did for 'giovani', namely this time as \in{segretario}[segretario] but it is not recognized. This is not the only non-working case. There are several.
Can anyone give me a hint as to what I might be doing wrong? I realise that usually these references call on page numbers or section numbers, but I don't want/need (or do I?) to use those. I simply the reader to be able to click on a hyperlink which takes them to the referenced entry.
Julian
If your question is of interest to others as well, please add an entry to the Wiki!
maillist : ntg-context@ntg.nl / http://www.ntg.nl/mailman/listinfo/ntg-context webpage : http://www.pragma-ade.nl / http://context.aanhet.net archive : https://bitbucket.org/phg/context-mirror/commits/ wiki : http://contextgarden.net ___________________________________________________________________________________
On 10 May 2022, at 04:03, jbf via ntg-context
wrote: Can anyone give me a hint as to what I might be doing wrong? I realise that usually these references call on page numbers or section numbers, but I don't want/need (or do I?) to use those. I simply the reader to be able to click on a hyperlink which takes them to the referenced entry.
Check for duplicates (referenced definitions with the same key). That problem has hit me a number of times. Best wishes, Taco — Taco Hoekwater E: taco@bittext.nl genderfluid (all pronouns)
participants (3)
-
Henning Hraban Ramm
-
jbf
-
Taco Hoekwater